After 12 years of waiting, I’m happy to say… I saw the new Superman movie with Clark Kent.
has to reckon with his Kryptonian heritage and his life on Earth while Luther tries to take him down.
I liked David Cornsweat in the movie; his Superman/Clark Kent feels like 80s Tom Hanks mixed with Brendan Fraser, which, hey, I’m always down for some Fraser influence. I wasn’t blown away by his interpretation of the character, but I thought it was a solid foundation, and I’m interested to see where the character goes from here.
I really enjoyed Rachel Brosnahan's take on Lois and her character. I’ve kind of wanted to see this characterization on the big screen for a while, and I’m glad I did. I think the Lois and Superman scenes are the heart of the film and were my favorite scenes. They felt very stripped down, heartfelt, and realistic. I’d say my biggest praise of this film is Cornsweat and Brosnahan’s performances, not to mention James Gunn’s writing and the 1970s-inspired minimalist directing, so my hats off to all that. 👏👏👏
I quite enjoyed Nicholas Holt’s performance; it was very intense and interesting, although a bit flat… It feels very similar to Colin Farrell’s performance in “The Batman.” You can see what he’s going for, and you like it, but there just isn’t enough substance to it to make it stand out. It just needed that little extra “it factor or to delve more into his motivation and psyche to make a pop… Like I know it’s cliché for a villain to go into a monologue and tell you a story from my past that explains why they are the way they are, but honestly I think we could’ve used the scene like that just to give Lex a little bit more personality and honestly, some of his dialogue towards the end gets very on the nose as far as what his character represent involving theme and motivation but Nicholas Hoult performance carries my enjoyment of this character through most of the film and I could definitely see my ranking and enjoyment of the character growing if he gets further development in future projects (like I did with Colin Farrell‘s Penguin after the penguin show) which they said Lex Luther is gonna be around so I’m sure we will but for right now he’s just good, but needs more time to cook
Jimmy Olsen got an interesting and funny subplot; it was probably my second favorite part of the whole film. It feels sort of like a fresh take on Jimmy while also playing into classic Jimmy themes and Jimmy feeling like Jimmy (man, I’m saying Jimmy a lot lol), but as a fan of the character, it was nice to see him get some fun stuff to do.
Strange to say, but I think my favorite character in this was Eve Teschmacher. I thought the actress gave a very comedic but oddly sweet performance, plus who she was interacting with and their whole plot led to some good chuckle moments, so I just got a real kick whenever she was on screen.
One of the big storylines has quite a bit of “modern social commentary,” and honestly, anytime they mentioned modern 2025 commentary, it was probably my least favorite part because it was so on the nose, and frankly, I’m tired of dealing with all the stuff in the real world because it’s so constant, in your face, not to mention everywhere. So while I do like some of the elements for their story potential, you can also tell it’s very personal for James Gunn, and I like when filmmakers get personal and put a lot of their heart into a movie, frankly… I don’t like having to deal with this in our real world, so watching Superman having to deal with it isn’t exactly a cakewalk.
The movie starts in an odd place, like it kind of feels like we’re missing a first act, and it leads to some very clunky, exposition-heavy dialogue through a good chunk of the first act and a half, which I thought could’ve been worked in better.
The Justice Gang was… ok. I think the standup was Mr. Terrific, who was… terrific 😂. He had a very cool characterization and one of the most interesting fight sequences I’ve seen in a superhero film in a while. I’m always going to be down to see Nathan Fillion in the sci-fi role, so that was a blast, and Hawk Girl was there. Not bad, but just very much in a supporting role, which I’m OK with.
There was a big sci-fi element introduced, which was probably my second least favorite part in the movie; it just felt a bit needless and didn’t add much to the story except for a very heavy CGI action scene, which I didn’t really care for, and to add some stakes to the climax, which didn’t really need to be there. This movie has enough going on, and it just felt like too much by the end.
The engineer was there and also OK… That’s all I really have to say about her.
I liked the scenes of Lois and Jimmy investigating; they felt very fast-paced, very Aaron Sorkin-esque.
I enjoyed the Daily Planet cast: Perry, Cat, Ron, and Steve (who I think will be a big comedic standout for most people), although they were a bit underserved, and I wish we had seen more of them. So right now they’re good, but I do think they need more time to cook, and I hope we get to see more development for them in the future because I think there’s more there to work with and explore.
Jonathan and Martha Kent were fine; they’re not in the movie a whole lot, but the parts they were in were nice… A bit standard usage of Ma and Pa, nothing that really stood out from previous incarnations of the characters, but still sweet and had some nice acting moments for the actors, so good for them.
Metamorpho is another character who is fine… I seem to be saying fine a lot in this review lol. There were interesting and fun uses of his powers; I would say walking out. I was just kind of positively indifferent towards him, like he was there and he did things… That’s about it for me.
I was disappointed with Ultraman; he kind of feels like an afterthought and, frankly, was a waste of an interesting idea.
Krypto was fine. I wish they had used a real dog for certain scenes instead of making the character completely CGI, but there were some cute and funny moments featuring the pup.
I like how kryptonite was depicted in the movie; he was one of the people more interested in effective uses of the rock I’ve seen in Superman media, and I thought there was a subtle inference to one of the themes of the movie in what the kryptonite, both metaphorically and physically, represents to Superman, so props and a gun for the creative choice there.
I like how they depicted Superman flying; it was definitely different but unique. I could see some people not dealing with it, but I was able to roll with it.
I thought the cinematography and color grading were good, the fight scenes were fine and standardly enjoyable… Although there was one part that felt like the most Power Rangers-esque fight I’ve ever seen, for good and for ill.
The Fortress of Solitude, the Daily Planet, Luther Corp., and the Kent Farm were all well-done sets, and very light spoiler… I think my favorite scenes were the ones in the Pentagon; I just love the way they were shot.
I was a little underwhelmed by the soundtrack; it wasn’t bad, just kind of bland.
There were a few cameos that I thought were cute; there was one right towards the end that was set up for something else, and without spoiling it… I’m actually quite interested to see where that goes; that could be quite interesting.
So, as you can see from all the different stuff I’m talking about… I have a lot of different thoughts and feelings about Superman (2025); honestly, there is too much. I understand James Gunn is not only trying to tell a Superman story but also set up a whole franchise/universe set-up film, and for what it is, it’s a pretty good introduction. There’s just a lot of fact in the story that, honestly, I wish could’ve been trimmed so we could get a more lean and cohesive movie, and the things I wish could’ve been expanded upon
I think one of the hardest parts about thinking back on Superman (2025) is how I’d rate it, because my thoughts and feelings are quite manic and all over the place. There are just a lot of elements coinciding for screen time all at once throughout the film, but the highs are quite high, and the lows are pretty low, so it’s been tricky. But here’s what I’ve surmised… Remember when you were a kid and your parents would tell you, “You have to finish your vegetables in order to have your dessert”? That’s kind of what it felt like during certain parts of the movie. I had to get through all the different plots and tones in order to get to the parts I like, which, like I said, are standouts. Unfortunately, there’s just too much fat going on in here that the film suffers and makes it hard to digest. I think if we had focused more on Clark & Lois’s relationship and Superman’s commitment to doing good and developed more of Lex Luther’s motivation, Ultraman, and developing the Daily Planet cast, I’d be more hyped on this movie. As of right now, for me personally, I give it between 3 and a half stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️/💫 and four stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️… but for regular audiences, I’d say a low four stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. I can’t say I didn’t have a good time, but it could’ve been leaner and stoned… But there’s enough here that work (and when it works, it really works well for me), that I think if James Gunn makes a more cohesive and leaner sequel, it would be something really special.